What the table actually means

Space versus age is the trade. Oak Hill gives you the most house at this number, about 2,053 square feet. Oak Hill gives you the newest, a median build year of 1990. You are choosing which one you care about, because at $400,000 you are not getting both.

Where this budget sits matters more than the house. In Casselberry the city median is $395,500, so $400,000 is an entry-level buy and you are competing at the bottom of that market. In Oak Hill the median is $390,000, so the same money is a mainstream purchase with more to choose from. That difference shapes how much room you have to negotiate.

The pool number surprises people. 36.0% of sales in this range in Casselberry had a private pool, against 25.0% in Oak Hill. If a pool matters, that single line should probably decide where you look.

Before you use these numbers

Medians describe a market, not a house. A specific street, a specific school zone, or a lot backing a preserve can move a price well outside these figures. Use this to pick where to look, then get a real read on the individual home.

See what is actually for sale right now

The numbers above are closed sales. These are the homes on the market today in that same price range:

Casselberry
single family homes ›townhomes ›

Questions about a specific address, or want the same cut run on a different budget or a different set of towns? Call or text Brenden Rendo at 407-616-9019.

Source. Stellar MLS closed sales, the 12 months ending August 26, 2026, single family homes only, filtered to listings cleared for public display. Condos, townhomes and manufactured homes are excluded because they pull a city median well below what a house costs. Data believed accurate but not guaranteed. Refreshed quarterly, current as of August 26, 2026.